Why Your Competitors Might Be Ranking Above You on Google (And What You Can Do About It)

Local SEOSearch OptimizationGoogle Business Profile

Example from Roe Digital's Compare Your Website tool: a business is #6 on Google Maps for roof repair in Jackson, Tennessee, while its competitor is #1 on Maps and #3 in regular results.

Have you ever searched for your business on Google and noticed competitors ranking above you? It can be frustrating, but Google is not favoring anyone. Your position in local search results comes down to a few specific factors. Understanding these can help you improve your visibility and reach more customers.

How Google Decides Which Local Businesses Show Up First

Google looks at three main factors: proximity, relevance, and prominence.

1. Proximity

Google wants to show users businesses that are close to their current location. If someone searches for “website company near me,” Google will prioritize companies located close to where that person is searching from. The searcher’s location influences the results.

This is also why your own search can be misleading. When you search from your office or your own phone, Google knows you are close to your business, and it may know you have searched for it or visited your website before. Because of that, you will often see your business higher than a customer across town does. To get a fair picture, look at the results the way a customer would see them, not just from where you sit.

2. Relevance

The more specific the search term, the more accurately Google can match it. A search for “website design companies in Jackson Tennessee” will usually place businesses with a clear match to that location and service (our own Jackson, TN web design page is written for exactly that search) near the top.

Relevance is where you have the most control. Choose the main category on your Google Business Profile that best describes what you do, and list your services. Give each main service its own page on your website. And say plainly which towns and areas you serve, so Google can connect you to those searches.

3. Prominence

Prominence reflects how well known and trusted a business is online. Google looks at reviews, website quality, mentions of your business, and activity level. Businesses that stay active, earn reviews, and maintain accurate listings tend to rank higher.

Of the three, proximity is the one you cannot change. Relevance and prominence are where your effort pays off.

See where you and a competitor show up

Enter your website, one competitor, and a service you offer. Our free tool runs a live Google search in your city and shows where you both land on Google Maps and in regular results, how the two websites compare, and three places to start. Because of proximity, it is a snapshot from one location: customers in other parts of town may see a different order.

Compare Your Website

How to Improve Your Google Ranking

The good news is that rankings can change. With consistent updates and accurate information, you can strengthen your position.

Keep your information consistent

Your business name, address, phone number, and hours should match across your Google Business Profile, website, and any other listings. Inconsistencies can lower your ranking.

Put your common questions and answers on your website

Google has retired the Questions and Answers section of Business Profiles. Instead, Google’s AI now answers people’s questions using information from your profile and your website. A page with clear answers to the questions customers ask you most gives both Google and your customers what they need.

Collect regular reviews

Frequent and recent reviews signal trust and activity. This directly impacts your prominence. Make it easy for happy customers to leave a review, and respond to the ones you receive.

Use an accurate business description

A well-written description tells customers what you do at a glance. Keep it accurate and make sure it matches the services on your website.

Post periodically

Simple updates on your Google Business Profile, like a recent project or a seasonal offer, show customers that your business is active. Google does not promise they improve your ranking, but they keep your profile current and give people one more reason to choose you.

More people are now getting answers from AI, like Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode or ChatGPT, instead of scrolling through a list of results. When someone asks for a local business, these tools lean on the same things covered above: your Google Business Profile, your reviews, your website, and what other sites say about you. Proximity still matters there too.

That means there is no separate trick for AI. Accurate, consistent information, steady reviews, and a website that clearly explains what you do and where you do it help you in regular search and in AI answers. If you want to see what AI tools say about your business today, try our free AI Visibility Checker, or read more in our post on generative engine optimization.

The Bottom Line

If you are not ranking where you want to right now, don’t worry. Local search results shift often. By keeping your information consistent, gathering reviews, and staying active online, you can improve your visibility and show up for the searches that matter most.

If you would rather have someone handle the profile, the listings, and the website side together, that is what our search optimization service covers.

Back to blog